Unstarving Musician | The only opinion that matters in music (according to a 2x Grammy A&R)


Happy Friday!

After 35 years of evaluating artists at the highest levels of the major-label system, what does an A&R executive actually believe matters?

Pete Ganbarg served as President of A&R at Atlantic Records from 2018 to 2024, capping nearly 16 years at the label. He now runs Pure Tone Music, sits on the Songwriters Hall of Fame board, and teaches at Berklee, NYU, Wesleyan, and the University of New Haven. He's seen what works, what doesn't, and what artists keep getting wrong.

Insights from our conversation

The audience is the only judge
Pete is blunt with his students. Nine out of ten won’t make it, and the only opinion that ultimately matters is the audience’s. He’s watched older A&R executives who believed their own taste was the deciding vote run into trouble because of this. He stands firm that the audience is always right.

The bar is quality
Asked for the one principle he’d give an independent artist to act on this week, Pete didn’t talk about marketing or strategy. He said elevate the bar of quality. In a world with no barrier to entry and distribution, quality is the edge that matters most.

Relationships are 50% (and so is showing up)
For artist-songwriters wondering where to focus, Pete pointed to sync and to craft. But the through-line was something more basic. Relationships are half of everything, and showing up is the other half.

🎧 Where to listen (plus show notes and related links)

Want the implementation-depth resources?

Liner Notes Insider goes deeper than a podcast episode can. Recent editions have covered things like royalty recovery tool kits, release planning templates, and revenue comparison calculators — the implementation layer beneath the episodes.

If you’re not yet a Liner Notes subscriber, the free edition covers highlights from this and 300+ conversations.

Liner Notes Insider gets you the complete frameworks.

This episode is brought to you by Podcast Startup.

Whether you're launching your first episode or adding video to your show, Podcast Startup eliminates the guesswork with the systems and strategies I've developed from producing 250+ podcast episodes—without the trial-and-error that cost me months. Learn more at ​UnstarvingMusician.com/PodcastStartup​.

🎧 Episode notes and related links

Peace, love and more cowbell,
Robonzo

Support the Unstarving Musician

If you find value in this podcast, please consider a donation via our online tip jar – click, tip, done.

Or visit UnstarvingMusician.com/CrowdSponsor to learn about the many other ways of showing your support.

Your support = love 💟

Share this email and/or read it on the web

Stay in touch!
Instagram | Facebook | YouTube| Threads| X (Twitter) | Bluesky

Feedback, comments, complaints? Reply to this email. I'd love to hear from you. 📭

UnstarvingMusician.com

Robonzo.com

Where to Listen to The Unstarving Musician

Click here to listen on Apple Podcasts

Click here to listen on Overcast

Click here to listen on Spotify

Click here to listen on YouTube

Click here to listen on Pandora

Click here to listen on Amazon

Click here to listen on iHeart Radio

The Unstarving Musician

I'm a musician and host of The Unstarving Musician podcast. Subscribe for conversations with working musicians, creative pros and industry professionals on the craft and business of sustainable creative careers.

Read more from The Unstarving Musician
Episode thumbnail artwork with headshot of Dan Scott, Spotlight Advisory Group.

Hello and happy Friday! Here's another new episode for your listening pleasure. My guest Dan Scott lives at the intersection of creativity, law, and financial freedom. Equal parts artist, strategist, and advisor, he has spent his career helping creatives build lives where their work, money, and purpose actually align. He works with musicians, artists, actors, founders, and independent creators to help them build sustainable careers through ownership, financial systems, brand strategy,...

Concert venue with a packed crowd facing a brightly lit stage framed by warm amber and white lights.

Hello and happy Friday! Here’s something most independent artists don’t think about: when someone buys a ticket through the venue’s platform, that person’s contact information belongs to the platform (not you). They come to your show, they leave, and you have no way to reach them again. Cody DeLong has spent more than a decade helping artists close that gap. He’s the CEO and co-founder of Sound Rink, a live-music technology company built around VIP experiences, artist pre-sales, and...

Happy Friday! What if the reason you’re ready to quit music has nothing to do with the music? Lynz Crichton joins me for the fourth time on the show. She’s a singer-songwriter based in Nottingham, England, and the creator of Music Marketing Method. The conversation started with an email she sent about a working musician named Matt who’d begun drafting the goodbye message for his website. Here are three insights from our conversation. Weariness Is Not the Same as Failure Lynz drew a line in...